The Central Prairie League released its All-League Football teams following the 2025 season.
The full teams are listed below. Athletes highlighted in bold represent local athletes. Asterisks (*) indicate unanimous selections.
Offensive Player of the Year: Kyle Huser (Victoria)
Defensive Player of the Year: Kyle Huser (Victoria)
FIRST TEAM
| Position | Player | Grade | School |
| Quarterback | *Braxton Alpers | Senior | St. John |
| Quarterback | Brodie Ctites | Junior | Central Plains |
| Running Back | *Weston Scherrer | Junior | Victoria |
| Running Back | Woodrow Lancaster | Junior | Kinsley |
| Utility Back | Austin Brack | Senior | Ellinwood |
| Tight End | Peyton Dody | Senior | Central Plains |
| Wide Receiver | *Rylan Siemsen | Senior | Central Plains |
| Wide Receiver | Kelson Juno | Senior | Otis-Bison |
| Offensive Lineman | *Landon Daniels | Senior | Central Plains |
| Offensive Lineman | *Kyle Huser | Senior | Victoria |
| Offensive Lineman | Trace Tudor | Junior | Ellinwood |
| Defensive Back | *Wes Sander | Senior | Victoria |
| Defensive Back | *Braxton Alpers | Senior | St. John |
| Defensive Back | Josh Stuckey | Sophomore | Kinsley |
| Linebacker | *Matt Pfeifer | Senior | Victoria |
| Linebacker | Wes Dreiling | Senior | Victoria |
| Linebacker | Aiden Ochs Lohrey | Sophomore | Otis-Bison |
| Defensive Line | *Landon Daniels | Senior | Central Plains |
| Defensive Line | *Kyle Huser | Senior | Victoria |
| Defensive Line | Alexander Hiemstra | Senior | La Crosse |
| Punter | *Trenton Skillett | Senior | La Crosse |
| Kicker | Easton Alpers | Sophomore | St. John |
| Punt Return | Hooper Castaneda | Junior | La Crosse |
| Kick Return | Humberto Rincon | Senior | Chase |
| Kick Return | Jace Reyes | Senior | St. John |
SECOND TEAM:
| Position | Player | Grade | School |
| Quarterback | Josh Stuckey | Sophomore | Kinsley |
| Running Back | Matt Pfeifer | Senior | Victoria |
| Running Back | Gavin Alloway | Senior | Otis-Bison |
| Utility Back | Richard Stroud | Senior | Central Plains |
| Utility Back | Lee Holopirek | Senior | La Crosse |
| Utility Back | Aiden Ochs Lohrey | Sophomore | Otis-Bison |
| Tight End | Marcus Starr | Sophomore | Otis-Bison |
| Tight End | Wes Sander | Senior | Victoria |
| Wide Receiver | Joey Prieto | Sophomore | Kinsley |
| Wide Receiver | Jace Reyes | Senior | St. John |
| Offensive Lineman | Gerardo Seanez | Senior | Kinsley |
| Offensive Lineman | Reece Morgan | Senior | La Crosse |
| Offensive Lineman | Cody Schmidtberger | Senior | Victoria |
| Defensive Back | Rylan Siemsen | Senior | Central Plains |
| Defensive Back | Peyton Dody | Senior | Central Plains |
| Defensive Back | Lee Holopirek | Senior | La Crosse |
| Linebacker | Austin Shinliver | Senior | Ellinwood |
| Linebacker | Woodrow Lancaster | Junior | Kinsley |
| Linebacker | Gavin Rose | Senior | Macksville |
| Defensive Line | Brady Kraft | Junior | Kinsley |
| Defensive Line | Cody Schmidtberger | Senior | Victoria |
| Defensive Line | Weston Scherrer | Junior | Victoria |
| Kicker | Alexander Hiemstra | Senior | La Crosse |
| Kicker | Ricky Martinez | Junior | Otis-Bison |
| Punter | Teagam Scheppman | Sophomore | Central Plains |
| Kick Return | Ty Hammeke | Senior | Ellinwood |
| Punt Return | Will Schmiedler | Senior | Victoria |
HONORABLE MENTION:
| Position | Player | Grade | School |
| Running Back | Broc Klima | Junior | Central Plains |
| Running Back | Leland Rice | Senior | Chase |
| Running Back | Drake Hosman | Senior | Ellinwood |
| Running Back | Braddix Bozarth | Senior | Ness City |
| Running Back | Daniel Portillo | Senior | St. John |
| Utility Back | Mason Mauch | Junior | Victoria |
| Tight End | Alexander Hiemstra | Senior | La Crosse |
| Wide Receiver | Ty Hammeke | Senior | Ellinwood |
| Wide Receiver | Jericho Mawhirter | Junior | St. John |
| Offensive Line | Peyton Kempke | Sophomore | Central Plains |
| Offensive Line | Brady Kraft | Junior | Kinsley |
| Offensive Line | Alex Randa | Senior | Ness City |
| Offensive Line | Thane Brenner | Junior | Ness City |
| Offensive Line | Juan Lozano | Sophomore | St. John |
| Offensive Line | Wes Dreiling | Senior | Victoria |
| Defensive Back | Keeton Robison | Sophomore | Central Plains |
| Defensive Back | Humberto Rincon | Senior | Chase |
| Defensive Back | Marcus Thielenhaus | Sophomore | La Crosse |
| Defensive Back | Travis Ross | Junior | Otis-Bison |
| Defensive Back | Will Schmeidler | Senior | Victoria |
| Linebacker | Richard Stroud | Senior | Central Plains |
| Linebacker | Drake Hosman | Senior | Ellinwood |
| Linebacker | Christian Rush | Junior | La Crosse |
| Defensive Line | Gaber Martinez | Senior | Ellinwood |
| Defensive Line | Nick Miller | Junior | Ellinwood |
| Defensive Line | Shain Granger | Senior | Macksville |
| Defensive Line | Marcus Starr | Sophomore | Otis-Bison |
| Defensive Line | Daniel Portillo | Senior | St. John |
| Defensive Line | Konner Schenk | Senior | Otis-Bison |
| Kicker | Weston Scherrer | Junior | Victoria |
| Kickoff Return | Konner Schenk | Senior | Otis-Bison |
| Punt Return | Ty Hammeke | Senior | Ellinwood |
| Punter | Kelson Juno | Senior | Otis-Bison |
