The Heart of America League released their First Team, Second Team, and Honorable Mention 11-man football players for the 2024 season.
The teams are listed below. The names in boldfaced font indicate unanimous selections.:
FIRST TEAM
Offense:
| POS | NAME | Gr. | SCHOOL |
| QB | Corey Crumrine | 12 | Sedgwick |
| RB | Zane Farney | 11 | Sterling |
| RB | Jameson Looper | 11 | Marion |
| RB | Kole Klaassen | 12 | Remington |
| WR | Spencer Crumrine | 9 | Sedgwick |
| WR | Dallas Lagree | 12 | Sedgwick |
| WR | Kaizer Kanitz | 11 | Moundridge |
| TE | Bear Moddelmog | 12 | Moundridge |
| OL | Braden DenHartog | 12 | Moundridge |
| OL | Murdoc Cochran | 12 | Sedgwick |
| OL | Cooper Wiens | 11 | Inman |
| OL | Luke Watkins | 12 | Marion |
| OL | Brian Nguyen | 12 | Marion |
| K | Cyrus Blough | 10 | Moundridge |
| Ret. | Kaizer Kanitz | 11 | Moundridge |
Defense:
| POS | NAME | Gr. | SCHOOL |
| DL | Cory Culp | 12 | Sedgwick |
| DL | Isaac Hammersmith | 11 | Trinity Catholic |
| DL | Cooper Wiens | 11 | Inman |
| DL | Braden DenHartog | 12 | Moundridge |
| LB | Gage Harris | 12 | Sedgwick |
| LB | Brian Nguyen | 12 | Marion |
| LB | Henry Hecox | 12 | Moundridge |
| LB | Matthew McConnaughy | 12 | Trinity Catholic |
| LB | Sebastian Martinez | 12 | Inman |
| LB | Isaac Jury | 12 | Remington |
| DB | Dallas Lagree | 12 | Sedgwick |
| DB | Wyatt Newberry | 11 | Sterling |
| DB | Malachi Brunk | 10 | Inman |
| DB | Kaizer Kanitz | 11 | Moundridge |
| P | Cyrus Blough | 10 | Moundridge |
| P | Corey Crumrine | 12 | Sedgwick |
SECOND TEAM
Offense:
| POS | NAME | Gr. | SCHOOL |
| QB | Henry Hecox | 12 | Moundridge |
| RB | Malachi Brunk | 10 | Inman |
| WR | Owen Luper | 11 | Sedgwick |
| WR | Korbyn McClellan | 10 | Inman |
| WR | Boston Ekart | 11 | Sterling |
| WR | Elliott Hochstetler | 10 | Remington |
| TE | Bentyn Chastain | 11 | Trinity Catholic |
| OL | Isaac Hammersmith | 11 | Trinity Catholic |
| OL | Waylon Schmidt | 12 | Sterling |
| OL | Kaden Mersman | 12 | Remington |
| OL | Layten Weins | 12 | Moundridge |
| OL | Cole McGinn | 11 | Sedgwick |
| OL | Kevin Ploutz | 11 | Sterling |
| Ret. | Korbyn McLellan | 10 | Inman |
| K | Dallas Lagree | 12 | Sedgwick |
Defense:
| POS | NAME | Gr. | SCHOOL |
| DL | Luke Watkins | 12 | Marion |
| DL | Kaden Mersman | 12 | Remington |
| DL | Teyton Savage | 12 | Sterling |
| DL | Ayden Johnston | 12 | Sedgwick |
| LB | Kole Klaassen | 12 | Remington |
| LB | Logan Isaac | 11 | Sterling |
| DB | Drew Dechant | 11 | Trinity Catholic |
| DB | Kellen Waner | 12 | Marion |
| DB | Zane Farney | 11 | Sterling |
| DB | Payge Rodenbeek | 12 | Bennington |
HONORABLE MENTION
Offense:
| POS | NAME | Gr. | SCHOOL |
| QB | Isaac Jury | 12 | Remington |
| QB | Drew Dechant | 11 | Trinity Catholic |
| RB | Wyatt Newberry | 11 | Sterling |
| WR | Drew Klaassen | 12 | Remington |
| WR | Kaid McElgunn | 11 | Trinity Catholic |
| WR | Isaiah Garrett | 11 | Bennington |
| TE | Kadon Mercer | 11 | Marion |
| OL | Garrett Campbell | 11 | Bennington |
| OL | Dylan Larson | 11 | Inman |
| OL | Layton Benjamin | 10 | Sedgwick |
| OL | Cale Thomas | 11 | Sterling |
| Ret. | Spencer Crumrine | 9 | Sedgwick |
| K | Lane Weigel | 9 | Sterling |
Defense:
| POS | NAME | Gr. | SCHOOL |
| DL | Jackson Bitonti | 12 | Marion |
| DL | Kadon Mercer | 11 | Marion |
| DL | Cale Thomas | 11 | Sterling |
| LB | Bentyn Chastain | 11 | Trinity Catholic |
| LB | Bear Moddelmog | 12 | Moundridge |
| LB | Jameson Looper | 11 | Marion |
| LB | Dylan Larson | 11 | Inman |
| LB | Paul Grill | 11 | Moundridge |
| LB | Mavrick Stauth | 11 | Sedgwick |
| LB | Aidan Suter-Tan | 12 | Trinity Catholic |
| DB | Drew Klaassen | 12 | Remington |
| DB | Jackson Dozier | 12 | Trinity Catholic |
| DB | Kru Harris | 9 | Inman |
| DB | Owen Luper | 11 | Sedgwick |
| P | Jameson Looper | 11 | Marion |
| P | Drew Dechant | 11 | Trinity Catholic |
